As a Mr. X put it rather rudely this morning:
[UPDATED: On August 9, several months after writing this email, Mr. X wrote to me and asked me to remove his name from this blog post. I am fully within my legal and moral rights not to, but I decided to comply because I was really happy with the way this blog post turned out].
From <REDACTED@gmail.com>
to akamenetz@fastcompany.com
date Thu, Apr 29, 2010 at 12:46 AM
subject Sophistry and Hypocrisy
I find it rather ironic that you (to the best of my knowledge) have failed to use the word sophistry in the free eight pages of text that I was able to read of your DIY U. Now I have to ask whether you believe knowledge should be free. If you say yes, then you must also make a case for why you are not a hypocrite. If you say no, you must also make a case for why you are not a hypocrite. If you choose not to respond I’ll be even more disappointed. If I chose to copy your book and put it online in PDF format and you sued me for copyright infringement when I freely distribute your text for anyone to read then I would see you as the god mother of sophist hypocrites.
I suppose you might read all of this as threatening and insulting, but that is not my intent. I’m only trying to determine which side you are on. Send me a copy of your book and I’ll read it front to back. Save a tree send it PDF. If it has merit, I’ll recommend it to anyone I know who will read it. If they want to pay for it then good for them and you. But I have a feeling I already learned about what you are saying from Socrates.
I wish you well if you are spreading good knowledge and people want to pay you for that. I wish you hell if you are just another sophist.
Maybe I am completely wrong. Please help me understand.
–
Mr. Shennen L. Dean
———————————————————————————
Others have asked the same question somewhat more politely. I will try to answer as simply as I can.
I am a human being, and I believe that human beings ought to be paid for their work.
I am a content creator, and I believe that content creators ought to be paid for their work.
I am a professional writer and journalist, not an academic or a performer, and it’s important to me therefore that I be paid specifically for my writing and reporting, not just for lecturing or other services, and by my readers, not just by other organizations.
1) That’s the most honest way for me to get paid. When I write for publications that rely on advertising revenue, the advertisers have a whisper of influence over the focus of what I write, no matter how much we like to pretend that they don’t. Even if it’s just in the sense that Fast Company is “a business magazine” and therefore my articles have to have something to do with business.
When I subsidize my writing with speaking engagements, I am taking time away from writing and I am collecting revenue directly from organizations that have particular agendas, such as corporations and universities.
2) Looking at it from the categorical imperative: If people like me can’t get paid directly by readers for writing, reporting and research that they conduct independently, then the world will have less of that kind of work, which I believe has value.
Does this stand conflict with the ideas I put forth in DIY U? I don’t think so. I support all content creators getting paid for their work. I think that the cost of educational content should drop to reflect the true cost of digital distribution (so I favor models like Flat World Knowledge). I also think educational content is somewhat different from what I do: it’s created explicitly as a public good using public funding, so it should be released as a public good once the creator has been amply rewarded for her time. Gifting one’s intellectual fruits to the masses is an act of noblesse oblige for those who enjoy the support, protection, and status of the academy (such as it is in these days). That said, I don’t want to be greedy! If and when I sell enough copies that Chelsea Green makes back the princely sum they advanced me, I would consider releasing it for free download once I regain the rights.
In conclusion, please buy my book! Or if Dean or someone else pirates it and puts it up on the web, or if you like the multiple excerpts you’ve read online on Scribd and elsewhere, you can always Paypal me a couple bucks directly.